Ludwell-Paradise Coach House and Stable (Garage)
Architectural Report, Block 18-1 Building 7B Lot 44Originally entitled: "Ludwell-Paradise Stable (Reconstructed)
Block 18, Building 7-B"

Singleton P. Moorehead

1933

Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library Research Report Series - 1412
Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library

Williamsburg, Virginia

1990

LUDWELL-PARADISE STABLE

(Reconstructed)

Block 18, Building 7-B (Col. Lot 44)

ARCHITECTURAL REPORT

by

Singleton P. Moorehead

March, 1933

Construction was started 2st February 1932

Construction was completed 10th June 1932

HOUSE: Paradise Stable

LOCATION: Block 18, Building 7-B

RECORD BY WHOM: S. P. Moorehead

DATE OF RECORD:

DATE OF TYPING: August 23, 1946

EXTERIOR.

GENERAL NOTES:

The decision of Restoration officials to make Paradise House and its outbuildings an exhibition group modifies the following notes. The only evidence of a stable in the group is an advertisement of sale of the lot and buildings, which mentions a "fine large stable and coach house," also stables and coach houses usually comprised a part of outbuilding groups accompanying substantial residences in Williamsburg of the eighteenth century. Thus no known conclusions from foundations or other wise were available, so that the demands of authenticity made by the decision to make the group an exhibition one had to be answered by the careful adherence to other known, colonial stables and coach houses.

The design comprises two portions - a brick stable part with a wood coach house wing. The brick portion was adapted from the brick stable at the old Tavern at Gloucester Court House, the brick stable at King William Court House and certain details from a brick storehouse at the Henley Estate, near Walkerton, The wood coach house was adapted very closely from a similar edifice on the Annie Catlett place, Port Royal Virginia, and the coach house at [?]

Old material came from following sources and is authentic, eighteenth century made up from the various following sources - but once delivered to the job or the wood working mill, pieces were culled from all the lots for specific uses - thus their geographic identity became lost - tags and chalk marks became effaced.

2

1.BrickClapton House, Charles City County, Va. Jones Farm, James City County, Va.
2.FramingClapton House, Charles City County, Va. Tettington, Charles City County, Va. Liberty Hall, Hanover County, Va.
3.SidingClapton House
4.FlooringClapton House Mostly from Oakland, Gloucester County, Va.

Brickwork: All exposed brick is eighteenth century brick from source (1) page 2. It is laid up in Flemish bond on outside - English on inside. The joints are as at Main Paradise House, and the mortar is made up to simulate the customary, local type of the eighteenth century by use of burned marl for lime. The marl is removed from the deposits along the banks of the James River - the same source as used by the colonists in this locality in the eighteenth century. Brick not exposed to the eye are common brick of modern manufacture.

Exterior Painting: Exterior doors and shutters painted sample #69-s. Trim and finish are painted a cold water paint similar in effect to whitewash. The cupola is painted with whitelead and oil.

The sample mentioned above is in the record sample files in possession of the architects and is an authentic eighteenth century color used in the vicinity. Ditto for the white.

3

NORTH ELEVATION.

SHINGLES: Mohawk Asbestos Shingles, Williamsburg Type. Developed specially for the Williamsburg Project to be fireproof yet imitate a weathered wood shingle. Insurance and soning requirements specify roofs to be fireproof. Roof boarding of antique material in stable - new common pine over coach house. A thickness of roofers felt was inserted under the shingles. This was necessary because shingles are other than wood. The sheathing had, therefore, to be tight - with close butt joints. This is in no sense a colonial method of roofing, but was done here because of the kind of shingle employed - nor does it offer a contradiction to a colonial appearance on the exterior. The old material for sheathing over stable was used because the hay loft was to have been exhibition, so rafters were of antique, colonial material and rightly the exposed sheathing had to be likewise. It was taken from source (3) page 2.

DORMER WINDOWS: None.

CUPOLA: Was adapted and simplified from Bremo Barn cupola. This was made of new material to architects details. The wood is heart cypress and southern yellow pine. All sheathing and boarding was rough sawn with hand saw to simulate a rough hand worked texture.

CORNICE: On coach house was adapted very closely from precedent at Port Royal - small barn on Annie Catlett place.

GUTTER AND LEADER: None.

WALL SURFACE: On stable of brick from source (1), page 2. See notes on brickwork, page 2. At points on the surface, headers were omitted 4" deep to simulate their feature so customary in colonial brick outbuildings. Precedent - 1. Carter's Grove flanking buildings, 2. Shirley barn, 3. Stratford barn.

4

On Coach House flush boards, forming a smooth surface about the two entrance doors. This is of antique material from source (3), page 2.

Cupola - see same, page 3.

POROH: None.

FRONT DOOR: Stable door #1, random width boards with capped, beaded joints on Z battens.. Simple, heavy frame. Adapted from old Tavern Stable, Gloucester Court House. Made of old material from sources (2) and (3), page 2. Ditto for hay-loft door above it. Flat arch of headers on edge to head brick openings is adapted from precedent at 1. Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable, 2. brick outbuilding at Henley Estate, near Walkerton.

Coach house doors #3 and #4 - double leaf doors of vertical, random width boards, capped, headed joints on Z battens. These are of old material from sources (2) and (3), page 2. Frames are cased around stud posts as at Port Royal barn. The doors are adapted from the Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable and from Mt. Airy Stable, also from The treatment of wall surface and frame with bead as at Port Royal barn. A post is driven into the ground at [illegible] of doors #3 and #4 to serve as a hooking base as well as a bottom stop for swing.

Door #1 is wide and high to accommodate the passage of horses - the dimensions being as at Gloucester Court House, Tavern Stable. Frames and aills of these openings in brick walls are joined by mortise tenon and pegs. The wide frames conceal, at the heads of openings, steel angles. These are inserted as a modern safety measure to prevent failure of brickwork above them.

The method of closing door against frame, rather than rebating frame to receive it is as at Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable and is also mentioned in eighteenth century stable specifications in possession of Department 5 of Research and Records.

WINDOWS: None.

SHUTTERS: None.

BASEMENT WALL: No basement under stable portion. Foundation wall under coach house high enough to free siding from contact of earth at grade and is a 9" thick wall in English bond. It is broken by the coach doors # and #4. The wall is of antique brick culled from source (1), page 2.

CHINNEIS: None.

BARGE BOARDS (END BOARDS) CORNER BOARDS: On Stable - barge boards of old material from source (3) and (4), page 2. They are beaded and taper towards peak as at brick outbuilding, Renley Estate, near Walkerton. The cornice stops are flush with these and are an adaptation from the above precedent.

Coach house - corner boards of old material, copied from precedent at Port Royal Barn.

GENERAL NOTES:

6

EAST ELEVATION.

SHINGLES: See North Elevation.

DORMER WINDOWS: None. For Cupola, see page 3.

CORNICE: On Stable - of a/slightly different type than on Coach House to indicate a different building. It is made of new material - heart cypress - run by modern milling methods to detail. Precedent for the beaded facia is the Annie Catlett Barn, Port Royal. The bed mould is adapted from Main Paradise House. The cyma is practically typical for wood - mid eighteenth century cornices in this vicinity.

GUTTER AND LEADER: None.

WALL SURFACE: Brick. See North Elevation for Stable. Coach house does not appear on this elevation.

PORCH: None.

FRONT DOOR: None.

WINDOWS: No windows, but narrow, vertical openings appear, splayed on inside. These have direct precedent at 1. Shirley barn, 2. Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable, 3. King William Court House Stable. Of these examples, (2) was followed most closely.

SHUTTERS: None.

BASEMENT WALL: None.

CHIMNEYS: None.

BARGE BOARDS (END BOARDS) CORNER BOARDS: None.

GENERAL NOTES:

7

SOUTH ELEVATION.

SHINGLES: See North Elevation.

DORMER WINDOWS: None.

CORNICE: Stable - none showing.

Coach House - see North Elevation.

GUTTER AND LEADER: None.

WALL SURFACE: Stable - see North Elevation.

Coach House - random width boards - joints lapped and running horisontally.

All of old material from source (3), page 2. The precedent for such treatment is small barn on Annie Catlett place, Port Royal.

PORCH: None.

FRONT DOOR: None.

WINDOWS: Stable: first floor has opening with infill of simple frame and square crossbars set diagonally and running horisontally, the whole opening having a sheathed shutter with Z battens. This treatment is specifically mentioned in records of Governor's Palace Stable and is further born out by precedent at 1. Stratford barn, 2. Shirley stable and barn, 3. Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable, Bars and frame are made up of new southern yellow pine to detail by modern mill manufacturing. The shutter is of old material from sources (2) and (3), page 2.

On second floor or loft and in gable is a louvred opening - louvres and Trame made new; see note above on frame and crossbars of first floor, windows. Precedent for such treatment: 1. Brandon brick storehouse, 2. louvred openings - Bruton Church, Williamsburg, 3. Port Royal Barn. Both frames and sills are joined with mortise, tenon and pegs. For brick treatment about these openings, see North Elevation; also for steel lintels.

8

SHUTTERS: See windows.

BASEMENT WALL: None for Stable. For Coach House, see note on North Elevation.

CHIMNEYS: None.

BARGE BOARDS (END BOARDS) CORNER BOARDS: Same as for North Elevation.

GENERAL NOTES:

9

WEST ELEVATION.

SHINGLES: See North Elevation.

DORMER WINDOWS: None. For Cupola, see North Elevation.

CORNICE: Ditto.

GUTTER AND LEADER: None.

WALL SURFACE: Stable - see North Elevation.

Coach house - see South Elevation. All exposed material on coach house, this elevation, is old and from sources as stated on page 1.

PORCH: None. Overhanging gable on coach house adapted in detail and very closely from Annie Catlett Barn in Port Royal, Virginia.

FRONT DOOR: Stable - door same as for that on North Elevation; window same as for that on South Elevation.

Coach House - door in gable loft or gallery a sheathed, beaded door on double Z battens - sheathing as at Annie Catlett barn, Port Royal, Virginis. Battens as at Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable. Frame and trim, etc. as at Port Royal barn. All of old material from source (3), page 2.

WINDOWS: No windows. Dove-cote openings as at Annie Catlett Barn, Port Royal, Virginia. See note on stable window above under Front Door.

SHUTTERS: For stable window, see under Windows - South Elevation.

BASEMENT WALL: Stable - none.

Coach House - see North Elevation.

CRIMNEYS: None.

BARGE BOARDS (END BOARDS) CORNER BOARDS: Barge boards on coach house as at Annie Catlett Barn, are of old material from sources (2) and (3), page 2. Ditto for corner boards and cornice stop.

None appear on stable, this elevation.

GENERAL NOTES:

10

INTERIOR.

GENERAL NOTES:

See page 1 regarding decision to make this building an exhibition structure. The intention was to make the interior exhibition as well as exterior. Thus the whole interior of stable was to be so treated and the space below the loft in Coach House. To accomplish this end, old material was to be used in all parts of these portions of the building which were to be exposed to the eye. The stable was to have its stalls, fodder rack, posts and harness pegs, loft ladder and trap door and access for tossing fodder to the racks in the stalls below. The floor in the stable was to have been brick with a drain gutter flowing out of the area through splayed openings in the exterior brick walls. Upon this basis complete drawings were made, the various details following closely known precedent at 1. Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable, 2. King William Court House Stable, while the floor and gutter were authenticated wall outlets uncovered on the outbuildings and dependencies of the Governor's Palace. The Coach House interior was to have a temped earth floor and exposed framing - all of it being very simple. This was completed as indicated and planned on the drawings, but a decision of the Williamsburg Holding Corporation to complete only those portions of the stable necessary for the structural requirements of the building postponed the insertion of most of the stable equipment until a future date to the time of this writing. In the following notes, the various portions of the interiors completed will be mentioned only.

11
FLOOR: FIRST (STABLE PORTION). ROOM: STABLE PART.

FLOOR: Cinders. See General Notes, page 10.

FLOOR NAILS: None.

BEAMS: None.

WALLS AND WALL COVERING: Brick in English bond. Brick are old from source (1), page 2. Precedent for exposed brick in English Bond, Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable.

CEILING: Of exposed joists and random width board floor. The former from source (2), page 2, the latter from source (4), page 2. Precedent, Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable, King William Court House Stable.

BASEBOARD: None.

DRAIR RAIL: None.

CORNICE: None.

PANELLING OR WAINSCOT: None.

MANTEL: None.

FIREPLACE AND HEARTH: None.

WINDOWS (SASH TRIM AND FRAME AND METAL WORK): See South Elevation. Metal work consists of handwrot hook eye to fasten shutter when closed. No trim on opening - same within as without. Hook eye hand wrot by local craftsmen after original colonial model bought from dealers.

The narrow openings are splayed on inside and have their heads and jambs coated with mortar - as Gloucester Court House Tavern Stable. See further notes on East Elevation. The shutter has 2 strap hinges on pintles driven into frame. These are copied by hand in wrot iron by a local craftsman after original colonial hinges bought from antique dealers.

CLOSETS: None.

12

DOOR AND TRIM: Door #1 and #2, see North Elevation. Door same within as without except swing is out. Door #5 to Coach House similar to exterior doors #2 and #1 - made up in same way and follows same precedent.

METAL WORK ON DOOR (LATCH, HINGES, DOOR KNOB, FASTENINGS, ETC.): Doors #1 and #2 have 3 strap hinges, the top and bottom having elbows. These are from same source as window shutter hinges noted above. Each door is equipped with padlock, chain and staple and hasp on frame. Same source as hinges.

Door #5 - 2 strap, pintle hinges, same source as hinges on window shutters above. A wood latch operated with rawhide pull and a wood keeper are used to shut door. These are copied in old material from an original colonial one bought from antique dealers in vicinity.

COLOR: Woodwork whitewashed.

EQUIPMENT: Ladder to loft - this is made up of old material from sources (2) and (3), page 2. Precedent follows that in King William Court House Stable. Some details being after the basement ladder at St. George Tucker House, Williamsburg, such as beading the tops of the stringers.

GENERAL NOTES: SEE General Notes, page 10.

13
FLOOR: FIRST. ROOM: COACH HOUSE.

FLOOR: Tamped earth. See General Notes, page 10.

FLOOR NAILS, None.

BEAMS: None.

WALLS AND WALL COVERING: See General Notes, page 10. Framing of studs, sills, corner posts, knees and braces are exposed, but constructed in colonial technique of framing after known precedent: 1. Mt. Stirling Barn, Charles City County, 2. Annie Catlett Barn, Port Royal. The material is old from source (2), page 2.

CEILING: Same as in stable, first floor.

BASEBOARD: None.

CHAIR RAIL: None.

CORNICE: None.

PANELLING OR WAINSCOT: None.

MANTEL: None.

FIREPLACE AND HEARTH: None.

WINDOWS (SASH TRIM AND FRAME AND METAL WORK): None.

CLOSETS: None.

DOOR AND TRIM: For coach doors #3 and #4, see notes on North Elevation: since there is no trim within, except cased rebate, the above reference is fully explanatory. Door #5 to stable, see First Floor, Stable.

METAL WORK ON DOOR (LATCH, HINGES, DOOR KNOB, FASTENINGS, ETC.): Coach doors #3 and #4 have same type hinges as doors #1 and #2 in first floor stable. Ditto for locks. The active valve has a hook which serves a staple in the wood stop post at grade. Hook from same source as window shutter hinge.

14

COLOR: All exposed surfaces whitewashed.

EQUIPMENT:

GENERAL NOTES: This room is fully completed as indicated on the drawings - see notes on page 10 regarding this matter.

15
FLOOR: SECOND. ROOM: STABLE LOFT.

FLOOR: Random width, rough boards from source (4), page 2. For further notes and precedent, see Ceiling, first floor stable. Since stalls were not built on first floor, the access to the stall racks for tossing fodder was not provided.

FLOOR NAILS: Modern cut nails, which simulate colonial wrot iron nails except for hand hammered surface.

BEAMS: See notes, stable, first floor, under Ceiling.

WALLS AND WALL COVERING: Roof rafters are antique from source (2), page 2. Roof boarding from source (3), page 2. These consist of wall surface.

CEILING: Ditto.

BASEBOARD: None.

CHAIR RAIL: None.

CORNICE: None.

PANELLING OR WAINSCOT: None.

MANTEL: None.

FIREPLACE AND HEARTH: None.

WINDOWS (SASH TRIM AND FRAME AND METAL WORK): For louvred window in south wall, see page 7. Only metal is a hook eye to fasten shutter when closed. This is hand wrot by local craftsman after original models procured from dealers in vicinity. The interior is similar to exterior in treatment.

CLOSETS: None.

DOOR AND TRIM: Door to outside in north gable, see notes on page 4. This is similar on inside to the outside.

Trap door to ladder from first floor - see General Notes, page 10. This is adapted very closely to a like feature in King William Court House Stable.

16

An access is provided by a batten, sheathed door to loft over Coach House. This made up like trap door.

METAL WORK ON DOOR (LATGH, HINGES, DOOR KNOB, FASTENINGS, ETC.): Gable door to outside has 2 strap, pintle hinges and a wrot hook and eye — all from same source as window hook above noted. Trapdoor has 2 strap hinges with T butts. Same source.

COLOR: Floor left natural. Other surfaces whitewashed.

EQUIPMENT:

GENERAL NOTES:

17
FLOOR: SECOND. ROOM: COACH HOUSE LOFT.

FLOOR: See Coach House, first floor, ceiling. Same as stable, second floor.

FLOOR NAILS: See page 15.

BEAMS: See references under Floor.

WALLS AND WALL COVERING: Made of new material since this area not considered exhibition.

CEILING: Ditto.

BASEBOARD: None.

CHAIR RAIL: None.

CORNICE: None.

PANELLING OR WAINSOOT: None.

MANTEL: None.

FIREPLACE AND HEARTH: None.

WINDOWS (SASH TRIM AND FRAME AND METAL WORK): None.

CLOSETS: 2 boxes built up of new material for dove-cotes - access doors provided. These made to provide space for birds but to keep them from any access to rest of loft. There is no precedent for these nor attempt to follow any.

DOOR AND TRIM: For gallery door, see West Elevation, Front door. METAL WORK ON DOOR (LATCH, HINGES, DOOR KNOB, FASTENINGS, ETC.): H and L hinges and wrot thumb latch. These from same sources as window shutter hardware.

COLOR: All surfaces white washed - floor natural.

EQUIPMENT:

18

GENERAL NOTES: Since this portion was not to be exhibition, the roof framing and boarding and the dove-cote boxes were made of rough sawn common pine.