Tarpley's Store Historical Report, Block 9 Building 41 AOriginally entitled: "Colonial Lot #20 - "Tarpley Store" Block 9 - Site #32"

Helen Bullock

1932

Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library Research Report Series - 1186
Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library

Williamsburg, Virginia

1990

COLONIAL LOT #20 - "TARPLEY STORE"
Block 9 - Site #32
June 27, 1932

obsolete

DIGEST OF DATA

Shop: Built prior to 1755 on corner lot 40 x 56, sold for£120 in 1759. In 1773 "commodious and well situated", a watchmakers shop, a printing office. Harwood accounts may apply see text. Story and half wooden house, dormers, 4 foot high brick foundation. Store and residence 1860. Burned.

COLONIAL LOT #20
Block 9 - Site #32
January 7, 1932

On the Southeast corner of Duke of Gloucester and Botetourt streets is a portion of a lot which was deeded separately from lot #20 on part of which the famous old Wetherburn's tavern [Richard Bland house] stands.

The first separate deed to this property is dated August 23, 1759, and indicates that a building was standing on the lot at this time. The deed follows:

1759 - August 23 (Book 6 Deeds) Henry Wetherburn, Tavern Keeper, to James Tarpley, merchant. Consideration: 120 pounds.
A certain part or piece of a lot of ground belonging to the said Henry Wetherburn, situate, lying and being on the south side of the Main or Duke of Gloucester Street in the said city of Williamsburg, denoted in the plan of the said City by the figures 20, to begin at the Northwest corner of the said lot and then to run eastwardly and along the line of the said lot on the said main street forty feet for front, thence southerly into the said lot 56 feet by a line parallel to the street marked in the Plan of the said city, by the letter L thence westerly 40 feet a parallel line to the first course and thence northwardly along the west side of the said lot to the beginning.
And all buildings ...

James Tarpley, the merchant, was in business with Tate and on October 10, 1755 advertised a very large stock of general merchandise in the Virginia Gazette. If he was established on lot #20 at this time it would place the date of the building at 1755 or before. Tarpley, however, owned a store on the present "Tucker" lot also.

After Tarpley's death his executors sold the portion of lot #20 "with the storehouse thereon" to Halcot, John and James Pride Page 2 on May 18, 1767 for£450, a very large consideration unless the building was of brick.

James Hubard, a merchant, rented this lot according to the Virginia Gazette:

1773 - October 14 (Purdie & Dixon, Eds.) FOR SALE,
The Commodious and well situated HOUSE and STORE on the Main Street in Williamsburg, formerly the Property of Mess. Tarpley and Thompson, and at present occupied by Mr. James Hubard. For Terms inquire of the Printer, or of the Subscriber in York Town.
RICHARD BROWN.

The store later became a watch and clock maker's establishment:

1774 - June 2 (Purdie & Dixon, Eds.) ROBERT BRUCE, WATCH and Clock Maker, is removed from Mr. Craig's, at the Golden Ball, to the opposite Side of the Street, the House above Mr. Robert Anderson's, where he intends carrying on his Business, and will be much obliged to those who may please to employ him.

Alexander Purdie, a printer who ended his partnership with John Dixon in 1774 and began to publish his own Virginia Gazette, took over this store at this time for his printing office and shop. He was also a book dealer and stationer.

1774 - December 1 (Purdie & Dixon, Eds.) …and those in this City who incline becoming Subscribers will be kind enough to leave their Names at my Office, which is the House formerly occupied by Mess. Tarply, Thompson & Co. on the main street, and adjoins Mr. Robert Anderson's Tavern …
ALEXANDER PURDIE.

James Pride, the owner of the lot, sold it to Alexander Purdie's executors on September 17, 1782 for£ 600. On September 30 of the same year they sold it to Samuel Beall, a merchant, for £ 3,000. Page 3 This latter price is in the inflated currency of the Revolutionary war period.

Samuel Beall, who owned the lot after 1782 had the following account in Humphrey Harwood's ledger. There is no record of his owning property in Williamsburg other than this large store although he owned a plantation quarter outside of the city. In Harwood's ledger after items dealing with plantation repairs he says "at the quarter" so the remaining items refer to extensive repairs and additions to this lot. A number of outbuildings are shown on the Frenchman's map which probably belong to Beall's store.

1778 November 14
To Repairing Chimney & laying harth 20/ 1: 0: 0
1779 May 27
To 2 bushs of lime 12/ & hair 1/ & mending of plastering 6/ 0:19: 0
To whitewashing a Room 30/ 1:10:0
Novembr 23
To 1750 Bricks a 69/1 pr ¢ & 26 Bushs of lime a 15/. to setting up a Grate & plasterg Oven£8:0:0 67:12: 0
To Building Ash House£ 20. & 3 Days labour a 40/ 26:11: 9
August 14
To bus 1/6 7 Repairing Store Steps 6/ & labours work 2/ 0: 9: 6
Septembr 4
To 600 bricks a 27/6 & 17 bushs of lime a 9d & 400 Tile a 5 pr ¢ 2: 7: 3
1783 Novemr 16
To 4 bushs of lime a 1/ & hair 4 d & Repairg Plastering 3/9 0: 8: 1
To whitewashing 2 Rooms a 4/6 & 2 Closets 4/6 0:13: 6
Decemr 3
To underpinning Smoak house 12/ & 2 days Labour 5/ 0:17: 0
To repairing larthing & plastering in Kitchen & upstairs to do 30/ 1:10: 0
Page 4
December 3
To repairing Stove & Oven 5/ & 7 days labour a 2/6 1: 2: 6
1784 June 24
To 8 bushels of lime 8/ & 3 bushs of whitwash a 2/ & 400 bricks 12/ 1: 6: 9
To repairing larthing & plastering 6/ & hair 6d 0: 6: 6
To do chimney & plastering do 5/ & 25 larths 6d 0: 5: 6
To whitwashing 3 Rooms & 3 passages at 4/6 1: 7: 0
To do 1 Room 4/6 & laying Dary floor &c 1: 8: 6
To 6 Days work y3 Dairy a 5/ & 4 days labour at 2: 0: 0
July 30
To 10 bushs of lime 10/ & plastering Chimney 2/6 0:12: 6
To whitwashing 1 Room 6/. & pointing 3 Chimnies 6/ 0:12: 6
To labours work 2/6. & larthing & plasterg 2 porchs 12/ 0:14: 6
Sepr 29
To 1 days work pinting underping to House 0: 6: 0
Novr 12
To rubing & laying 2 harths 12/ & Mendg 2 backs 5/ 0:17: 0
To plastering 2 fire places 3/ & hair 4d 0: 3: 4
To whitewashing 1 Room & small passage 7/6 0: 7: 6
To repairing plastering in Chamber & Upstairs 2/6 0: 2: 6
To laying porch floor & mending cellar Wall 0: 6: 0
1785 July 2
To Building 2 pr Steps to D. House 20/. & 1. do to Nesecary 6/. 1: 6: 0
To underpining Nesecary 10/. & larthing & plastering do 12/ 1: 2: 0
To Repairing Kitching Chimney & Oven 7/6. & 500 larths a 1/6 0:15: 0
Page 5
July 5
To 10 bushs lime 10/. 334 bricks a 3/. & Buildg pr Steps to Store 15 1:15: 0
To Altering the Spring 6/. Repairing Celler Steps & Wall 7/6 0: 13:0
To Repairing back in Dining Room 2/6. & 3 days labr a 2/6 0:10: 0
1786 Septemr 16
To Repairing Nursery. & C[h]amber, & Dining Room back 7/6 0: 7: 6
Octobr 8
To whitewash. 1/ & whitewashing 1 Room 4/6 0: 5: 6
1787 Decemr 1
To laying 2 Hearths & repairing 2 Backs a 2/6 0:10: 0
February 4
To rebuilding Oven 10/. & Repair ing kitchen back 3/9 0:13: 9
To laying kitchen harth 3/9 & 3 days labr a 2/6 0:11: 3

There are no insurance policies on this property but Mr. Charles in his "Recollections of Williamsburg" gives this detailed description of the building on this site prior to 1870:

"A very old house stood, up to the seventies, at the north west corner of the square bounded by the Duke of Gloucester, Francis, Botetourt, and Blair Streets. This house bore every evidence of having been here in early Colonial Days. It was a story-and-&-half wooden structure of moderate size, and was built on a brick foundation about four feet high, and had dormer windows. The end toward the Duke of Gloucester Street was used as a store, and the balance as a residence. It was destroyed by fire, and at that time the upstairs was reached by steps on the eastern outside of the house. The site of this old house is now occupied by one of Pender's Stores."

Harold R. Shurtleff, Director
Department of Research & Record

ab
Report by: Helen Bullock
cc: P. S. & H., Boston and
Williamsburg.
Dr. W. A. R. Goodwin
A. A. Shurcliff.

NOTE
Colonial Lot #20

Since Mr. Charles in his "Recollections of Williamsburg" says this was a wooden building on a high brick foundation there are two possibilities; one is that the original store was brick and a wooden house was erected on the foundations later. It also is possible that the original building was of wood but was large and well constructed which would account for the large consideration always paid for it. Excavation should determine this point.

Beall's accounts in Harwood's ledger begin four years before he purchased the building but while he was a tenant in it. Tenants often repaired the building which they leased on long term leases.

When this building is wrecked the brick part should be preserved until an archaeologist has determined that it is not part of the older building.

DEPARTMENT OF RESEARCH & RECORD.
HB/ab

July 20, 1935.

Miss Pattie Morecock
Williamsburg
Virginia

Dear Miss Morecock,

The Research Department records show the following:

That the lot at the southeast corner of the Duke of Gloucester Street and Botetourt Street was owned in 1759 by James Tarpley, merchant, who purchased it from Henry Wetherburn, the famous tavern keeper whose famous tavern-now known as the Richard Bland house- stood just to the east of it.

After Tarpley's death his executors sold the lot "with the storehouse thereon" to Halcot and John and James Pride in 1767.

The Virginia Gazette for October 14, 1773 shows that James Hubard, merchant, rented this property at that date. In 1774 the store was a watch and clock makers shop, run by Robert Bruce and later in this same year it was rented to Alexander Purdie, who-having just ended his partnership with John Dixon-started to publish his own Virginia Gazette here. In 1782 James Pride, who still owned the lot and building, sold it to Alexander Purdie's executors who resold it the same year to Sam. Beall.

Mr. Charles in his "Recollections of Williamsburg" describes the building on this lot as it looked before 1870 as a very old wooden story-and-a-half house with dormer windows, one end of which-the end toward the Duke of Gloucester Streetreversed [illegible] on Charles lt. B-was used as a residence, while the other end was used as a store. Its second floor was reached by an outside staircase. He adds that the building was destroyed by fire.

Sincerely yours,
Harold R. Shurtleff

HRS:mrm

Colonial Lot 20 - Purdie's Gazette
(Block 9)

1759, Aug. 23, Henry Wetherburn sold to James Tarpley1 a part of lot 20 on the south side of the Duke of Gloucester Street. The dimensions of the lot sold to Tarpley were 40' x 56'. The western boundary of Tarpley's lot was described as Street L.

Wetherburn, Henry and Anne, his wife - Tavern Keeper
to
Tarpley, James, Merchant
Consideration: 120 pounds Current Money of Virginia

A certain part or piece of a lot of ground belonging to the said Henry Wetherburn, situate, lying and being on the south side of the Main or Duke of Gloucester Street in the said city of Williamsburg, denoted in the plan of the said City by the figures 20, to begin at the Northwest corner of the said lot and thence to run eastwardly and along the line of the said lot on the said main street forty feet for front, thence southerly into the said lot 56 feet by a line parallel to the street marked in the Plan of the said city by the letter L thence westerly 40 feet a parallel line to the first course and thence northwardly along the west side of the said lot to the beginning.
And all buildings … (York County Records, VI, Deeds, 212.)

The street west of Lot 20 is marked "Botetourt", and "L" on the Unknown Draftsman's Map.

1767, May 18, Thomas Everard and David Jameson, executors of James Tarpley sold to Halcot, John, and James Pride, for 450 pounds, Lot 20 - the same dimensions and boundaries as in the deed from Wetherburn to Tarpley of 1759 - with the storehouse thereon. (York County Records, VII, Deeds, 284-286.)

2
1774, Dec. 8, (Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon)

WILLIAMSBURG, December 1, 1774.


Immediately after Christmas, I shall begin doing Business for myself, and intend to print a GAZETTE as soon as I am furnished with a moderate Number of Customers … those in the City who incline becoming Subscribers will be kind enough to leave their Names at my Office, which is the House formerly occupied by Mess. Tarpley, Thompson, & Co. on the main Street, and adjoins Mr. Robert Anderson's Tavern.1 . . .
Meanwhile, I have opened a large and valuable Collection of NEW BOOKS, amongst them a great Variety for the Use of Schools; which, together with a well chosen Parcel of MUSICK, for the Harpsichord, Violin &c and a Number of STATIONARY ARTICLES, will be disposed of on the easiest and very best Terms . . .
ALEXANDER PURDIE
1775, Jan. 14, (Virginia Gazette, Dixon & Hunter) AS I am now busily employed in fixing up my PRINTING OFFICE, the Materials for which I have just received from Philadelphia, the Publick may depend upon being furnished, in the first Week in February, with the VIRGINIA GAZETTE printed by
Their obedient humble Servant,
ALEXANDER PURDIE

The first issue of 1775 is dated February 3.

3
1775, Oct. 13, (Virginia Gazette, Alexander Purdie, Ed. Supplement.) The CONSTITUTIONAL POST being now established, all letters for the Northward, or that are to be forwarded to the different parts of this Colony, North or South Carolina, Georgia, &c. must be sent to my office, the Hon. BENJAMIN FRANKLIN, esq; having been pleased to appoint me postmaster in Williamsburg, under the authority of the GENERAL CONGRESS.
ALEXANDER PURDIE

1776, May 17, Alexander Purdie, advertised books and writing paper for sale at the Constitutional Post Office in Williamsburg. (Virginia Gazette, Alexander Purdie.)

1776, June 28, Alexander Purdie, D[eputy?] Postmaster, was appointed by the Postmaster General of the Constitutional Post Office as the proper person to receive accounts of the following [post] offices … (Virginia Gazette, Alexander Purdie, Card #2299.)

1777, Mch. 28, (Virginia Gazette, Purdie [Hunter] & Dixon.)

WILLIAMSBURG, March 28, 1777.

The following Articles of Merchandise are for Sale at the Brick House next Door above Mr. Purdie's Printing Office, Wholesale or Retail, viz. PAPER, HATS, SHOES, LINEN, ready made SHIRTS, DRUGS and MEDICINES, best Bourdeaux WINE, and a great Variety of other Things, by
MILON & HORANCE.

1779, April 12, Alexander Purdie, will of:

April 12, 1779


I Give and devise to my Nephew John Clarkson one Mourning Ring of the value of Fifteen pounds sterling —


I give and devise to my Executors herein after named all the rest and residue of my Estate both real & personal to be sold by them …


I do hereby appoint my Friends John Minson Galt and Robert Anderson Executors of this my Will …

(York County Records, 22, Wills and Inventories, p. 419.)

4
1779, May 8, (Virginia Gazette, Dixon & Nicolson, Ed.)

To be SOLD to the highest bidder, for ready money, on Tuesday the 18th instant (May) at the late dwellinghouse of Mr. Alexander Purdie, deceased,
ALL his personal estate, consisting of a great variety of exceeding good household and kitchen furniture, 130 ounces of plate, two horses and saddles, a neat Italian riding chair and harness, and nine slaves, amongst them a carpenter, gardener, and cook. Also his printing materials and a few books. Likewise his dwellinghouse1 and lots, and printing office, together with the unexpired lease of the adjoining house, used as a composing and press room. Possession of the dwellinghouse will be given the first of October, and the office immediately.

RO. ANDERSON, )

... J. M. GALT, ) Executors.

5

A deed quoted below shows that Purdie's executors sold Lot 20 to Samuel Beall, merchant, on June 20th, 1779. All deeds concerned with Lot 20 are quoted below:

September 17, 1782

Pride, James
James City County
to
Galt, John Minson ) Executors
Anderson, Robert ) Alexander Purdie.

This Indenture . . . between James Pride and John Minson Galt and Robert Anderson executors of the last Will and Testament of Alexander Purdie deceased on the other part for£600 current money of Virginia by the said Alexander Purdie in his lifetime to the said James Pride paid or caused to be paid the Receipt whereof the said James Pride doth hereby acknowledge and thereof acquit and discharge the said John Minson Galt and Robt Anderson their Executors and Administrators He the said James Pride hath granted bargained Sold aliened enfeoffed and confirmed and by these Presents doth grant bargain sell alien enfeoff and confirm unto the said John Minson Galt and Robt Anderson their Heirs and assigns forever all that piece or parcel of Land situate lying and being in the County of York and - [sic] on the Duke of Gloucester Street on the East by the Lott of Henry Nicholson on the South by the said Nicholsons Lott and on the West by by [sic] Pump Street being part of that Lott or parcel of Land denoted in the plan of the City of Williamsburg by the Figure or Number 20 and which said Piece or Parcel of Land was sold and . . . [sic] conveyed by Henry Wetherburn formerly of the City of Williamsburg to Messers Tarpley & Thompson of the said City Merchants and by the said Tarpley & Thompson sold to the said James Pride and all houses etc . . .

(York County Records, VI, Late eighteenth century records, Deeds, 139)

September 30, 1782

Galt, John Minson ) Executors
Anderson, Robert ) Alexander Purdie
to
Beall, Samuel - merchant
Williamsburg.
Consideration: 3000 Pounds.

All that piece or parcel of land, situate, lying and being in the County of York, City of Williamsburg, being part of the lot or 6 half acre of land denoted in the plan thereof by the figures or numbers 20, and bounded on the North by the Duke of Gloucester Street, on the East by the lot of Henry Nicholson, on the South by the said Nicholson's lot, and on the West by Pump Street, being the parcel of land now in the possession of the said Samuel Beall, which was sold and conveyed by Messrs. Tarpley and Thompson, merchants to James Pride, and by the said Pride to John M. Galt and Robert Anderson, September 17, 1782.
All houses, buildings . . . (Ibid., p. 140)

[Oct. 21, 1782]

Indenture . . . between John Minson Galt and Robert Anderson Executors of the last Will and Testament of Alexander Purdie deceased in the City of Williamsburg of the one part and Samuel Beall of the said City Merchant of the other part . . . for£3000 paper Currency of Virginia by the said Samuel Beall to the said Executors in the Month of June, 1779 in the hand paid whereof the said John Minson Galt and Robert Anderson do hereby acknowledge and thereof acquit and discharge the said Samuel Beall his Executors and Administrators They the said Galt and Anderson have granted bargained sold aliened enfeoffed . . . that part of lot # 20 [boundaries same as in deed of September 17, 1782] now in the Tenure and Possession of the said Samuel Beall. (Ibid., p. )

In the twentieth century, Mr. Charles recalled the appearance of the house that stood on Lot 20 at the time of the Civil War:

A very old house stood, up to the seventies, at the north west corner of the square bounded by the Duke of Gloucester, Francis, Botetourt and Blair streets. This house bore every evidence of having been there in early colonial days. It was a story and a half wooden structure of moderate size, and was built on a brick foundation about four feet high, and had dormer windows. The end toward Duke of Gloucester street was used as a store, and the balance as a residence. It was destroyed by fire, and at that time, the upstairs was reached by steps on the eastern side of the house. The site of this old house is now occupied by Pender's store. (Recollections of Mr. John S. Charles, Typed notes in Research Department, p. 51.)

Footnotes

^1 Later deeds in this report show that Tarpley used this lot for the business of the merchants, Tarpley and Thompson.
^1 From a chain of sources, it appears that Robert Anderson kept a tavern at the former Wetherburn Tavern from March 7, 1771 to September 22, 1779. (See Wetherburn House History, Feb. 1943, pp. 15, 17.) On May 2, 1771 (Virginia Gazette, Purdie and Dixon), Margaret Hunter advertised her millinery shop "next Door to Mr. RobertAnderson's Tavern." On June 20, 1771, she advertised that she was removed to "the Corner Store in Doctor Carter's Brick House." (Ibid.) It is impossible to say whether she retained the location referred to on May 2, or had moved to Dr. James Carter's brick house on Lot 53.
Further proof of Robert Anderson's location was given by the watchmaker, Robert Bruce, who announced on June 2, 1774 that he had moved from the Golden Ball [Lot 53] "to the opposite Side of the Street, the House above Mr. Robert Anderson's …" (Virginia Gazette, Purdie & Dixon) A William Rowsay in 1786 offered to sell the house he lived in. He described it as a well frequented tavern on the Main Street, nearly opposite the Rawleigh formerly occupied by Mr. Southall, and afterwards by Mr. Anderson. (See Wetherburn Report, p. 20) On the Unknown Draftsman's Map, the name "Rowsay" appears on Lots 20 and 21.
^1 Purdie's dwellinghouse and lot (24) were sold to Thomas Cartwright. Date of deed was February 21, 1780:
Galt, John Minson - ) Executors
Anderson, Robert ) Alexander Purdie, dec'd.
Williamsburg, Va.
to February 21, 1780
Cartwright, Thomas
Same Place.
Consideration: 5225 Pounds
All that lot or parcel of land in the city of Williamsburg on the South side of the Duke of Gloucester Street, whereon the said Alexander Purdie in his lifetime resided and bounded on the East by the lot of William Goodson, on the North by the Duke of Gloucester St., on the West by the lot of Jane Vobe and on the South by Francis Street, denoted in the plan of the said city by the figures 24. Which above property belonged to Alexander Purdie and was by his last will and testament ordered to be sold to the highest bidder at public auction.
And all houses, etc. (York County Records, Deeds, Book VI, 92)

In 1783 this property was offered for sale. There is nothing in the advertisement that throws any light on a printing shop or adjoining house which Purdie used for a composing room.
October 18, 1783
BETWEEN the hours of two and three o'clock in the afternoon, on the second Monday in January next, before the Raleigh-Tavern door (if not before that time disposed of at private sale) by virtue of a power of attorney from Thomas Cartwright to the subscriber, the said Cartwright's LOT and HOUSES in Williamsburg, viz. a large commodious dwelling-house, with four rooms on a floor, a kitchen, stable, and other convenient outhouses, situate on the main street, between Mrs. Vobe's and the capitol. One half the purchase money to be paid at the sale, when a title will be made; the other half at the ends of six months, on giving bond with approved security to
ALLEN JONES.
York-Town, October 1783.
[Virginia Gazette or the American Advertiser, James Hayes]