Wetherburn's Tavern Architectural Report Block 9 Building 31 Lots 20 & 21Originally entitled: "Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern Block 9, Building 31 Summary Architectural Report"

J. F. Waite

1968

Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library Research Report Series — 1175
Colonial Williamsburg Foundation Library

Williamsburg, Virginia

1990

MR. WETHERBURN'S TAVERN
BLOCK 9, BUILDING 31
SUMMARY ARCHITECTURAL REPORT

Restoration work begun: November 22, 1966
Restoration work completed: July 1, 1968
The Summary Architectural Report is a resume of information on the subject building, condensed from data filed in the Architects' Office. It is intended for use by authorized personnel within Colonial Williamsburg, and by visitors having a serious interest in colonial American architecture. It is not for public distribution.

J. F. Waite
March 28, 1968

RR117501 Wetherburn's Tavern Bl. 9 Bldg. 31 December 1967 67-SMT-2759 The building is shown before the prime coat was covered with simulated whitewash.

RR117502 First Floor Plan

RR117503 Second Floor Plan

SUMMARY ARCHITECTURAL REPORT MR. WETHERBURN'S TAVERN BLOCK 9, BUILDING 31

The two lots (colonial Lot Numbers 20 and 21) on which Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern was later built were purchased from the Trustees of the City in or before 1716 by Richard Bland, Merchant and Burgess. The property, with whatever buildings Bland built on it, was purchased in 1727 by Nathaniel Harrison of "Wakefield", Surry County. Harrison died shortly thereafterin 1727 and the property was left to his son Benjamin, who held it until 1738. In that year colonial Lots #21 and X22 were purchased by Henry Wetherburn, tavern keeper. The exact date when Henry Wetherburn acquired colonial lot #20 is not known. (Note: for complete information about ownership biographical materials, etc.., see Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern Research Report by Mary A. Stevenson.)

Shortly after his purchase of the property,and probably by 1742, Henry Wetherburn built the first (east) portion of the extant tavern building, which will be explained in the following text. A large addition to the west was added by 1752. This with the original eastern portion, forms the facade which, restored, faces the Duke of Gloucester Street today. Between 1755 and 1760 a shed wing was added to the southeast rear corner.

After Wetherburn's death in 1760 the building had a succession of owners and was subjected to differing uses throughout the eighteenth, nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The property and building was purchased in 1918 by Mrs. Virginia Bruce Haughwout, who held it until her death in 1956. Colonial William burg, Inc., leased the property from Mrs. Haughwout's estate in 1964 for a period of 100 years with the privilege of restoring the eighteenth century tavern building, removing modern additions and outbuildings,etc.

Beginning in 1965 the building was subjected to intensive architectural and archaeological investigations. Armed with the findings of these investigations, working drawings specifications etc, were drawn up and the physical work of restoration work began in 1967.

In the following Summary Report the various building phases will be briefly discussed and their architectural features noted, with emphasis on the original pieces still in place. The exterior will be explained first, one elevation at a time, and various rooms will then be explained.

Page 2

EXTERIOR

NORTH ELEVATION

The building which Wetherburn built first comprises the eastern section of this facade, including the five dormers and the windows and door below them. This building was of typical plan, with four rooms symmetrically arranged, two on either side of a through center passage which contains the stair. The west end of this first building is marked by a beaded cornerboard east of the west door, and by a break in the brick foundation wall at that point. The remainder of the building to the west comprises the addition of the 1750's and matches in architectural character the older part of the building.

The roof shingles on the entire building are fire proof cement asbestos simulating the original round-butt wood shingles. The dormers in the jerkin head roof have their original framing in place and some of the trim. The sashes, the horizontal beaded weatherboards on the cheeks and the trim was missing, and has been replaced with new material whose design is determined by marks on the original frame, etc. (Note: in this report the word "new" indicates work put in the building at the time of restoration, copied from original matching material in the building or using suitable precedent from eighteenth century Tidewater Virginia architecture. The word "modern" is used to indicate work installed between 1850 and 1965.)

The chimneys seen above the roof are all new, those existing at the time of the restoration being modern and in poor condition.

The cornice on the north elevation is a typical eighteenth century modillioned cornice, put on late in the eighteenth century to replace an earlier cornice. It is original except for patching and for thecrown mold which is new.

The weatherboards on this elevation are all new, matching originals elsewhere on the building. The beaded cornerboards are also new.

The first exterior paint applied to the different portions of the original building was a Spanish Brown primer. Whitewash was then applied over this. This whitewash was visible until covered with various nineteenth and twentieth century paints. The restored building has been painted with a primer resembling the original Spanish Brown, and over this a heavy coat of simulated whitewash has been applied, brushed on in a manner resembling the original application. The simulated whitewash is in fact oil base paint thickened with sheetrock joint cement.

Both porches on this elevation are new, archaeological and architectural investigations having determined their location and width. (Note: in the nineteenth century major alterations to the building were carried out, which on the exterior included replacing doors with windows and vice versa, removing original porches and adding modern porches, etc. This alteration will be noted Page 3 in more detail in the interior notes to follow.)

Both doors on this elevation are new, but the jambs of the east doorway are original. Both of the doors fell victim to the nineteenth century alterations, but the east door jambs, which are actually wall. posts finished as door jambs, were left in place when the door was removed. In each case marks in the framing indicated the height and width of the door, the size of the transom, and other details which assure the accuracy of the restored openings.

With one exception, all the window frames on this elevation are original, patched as necessary. The exception is the third window from the east which is entirely new. The sashes in the eastern portion of the building are new, but the sashes in the western addition are original, with much original glass still in place. All paneled shutters are new, as is the shutter hardware with the exception of the shutter holdbacks, which are largely original on this elevation.

The brick foundation wall of this elevation is largely original, with much patching especially around the jambs of the basement window grilles. As noted above, the joint in the brickwork east of the west door marks the original west line of the original building. The numerous cuts in the brickwork of the foundation wall are a result of nineteenth century changes where the brick were hacked to better secure a stucco coat which was applied and scored to resemble stone. The stucco was applied over earlier nineteenth century coats of whitewash and red paint.

The basement grilles and frames on either side of the east porch and the two in the western addition are the originals, patched and repaired as necessary. The others are new. All interior batten type shutters are new.

EAST ELEVATION

There are no dormers on the east elevation, but the form of the jerkin head roof is very evident. This roof form La typical of the first quarter of the eighteenth century, and has many counterparts in Tidewater architecture of that period. The form evolved earlier in England, and provided a means whereby the end of a building could be overhung by the thatch roof and still provide maximum room on the second floor. The style carried over into the second quarter of the eighteenth century, although thatch was not a roofing material in the eighteenth century here. Also, the shed addition to the rear is evident. The rake boards at the roof line on this elevation are new.

All the weatherboards on the east elevation are new, again following the precedent of originals in other locations on the building. The cornerboards are also new.

Both windows on this elevation are new. The large one in the east wall of the shed addition would have been located originally in the rear wall of the southeast room. When the shed was built the window in the rear wall was located Page 4 in this position. The small window would originally have lighted the east wall of this same small rear room. The shutters and hardware are also new.

The brick foundation wall of the main building is largely original, but that of the shed addition is new, the old one having been in too poor condition to retain. Nineteenth century whitewash and red paint were in evidence as on the north elevation.

SOUTH ELEVATION

The south elevation of Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern present the most involved facade of the building. The shed addition is visible on the east, and a long porch,added after the west addition but before the shed.ties the three portions of the building together. Remembering the sequence of original building and additions is useful in understanding the details which follow.

As noted above, the roof is covered with cement asbestos round—butt shingles in imitation of the original wood shingles. When the shed addition was built, its roof framing was fastened to the original rear roof just under the second floor dormer. In the space thus enclosed between the roofs was found four courses of the original wood shingles still in place, having been protected for about 200 years by the new roof above. These shingles, in situ, made possible a faithful and accurate restoration of shingle width, length, arrangement, etc. Note the square butt starter course which assured an even drip of roof water away from the building.

The six dormers on the south elevation contain much of their original framing, patched and repaired, but the sash, frame, cornice and roofing are all new. The dormers in the west addition are located over corresponding windows below. Those in the oldest portion of the building were originally centered over rear windows and the central one. located in the center of the building, although not over the rear door.

As noted on the north elevation, the chimneys above the roof are all new.

The cornice across the south elevation is new with the exception of a small portion of the soffit near the west end of the building. It is simpler than the north cornice in that it has no modillions and a smaller projection. The sample cornice across the shed addition is also new.

The south elevation contains the only original weatherboards remaining on the building. Original examples are in place to the east of the west door, west of the west door, and between the three windows of the western addition. The remainder of the weatherboards on the elevation are new, their design and spacing matching that of the originals. All cornerboards are new. Note that at the junction of the shed addition with the original rear wall no cornerboard was ever installed.

Page 5

The porch on the south elevation is a reconstruction based on evidence found by archaeological and architectural investigation. There were two early small porches at the original rear door, and one was installed at the west door when the addition was built. These were superseded, however, by a long roofed porch which covered, in addition to the porch floors themselves, a bulkhead into the basement under the original building. There was a bulkhead immediately to the east of the rear door originally, but this was closed up shortly after the building was built, and another added, to be later covered by the porch. There is still another bulkhead leading into the basement under the western addition. Both bulkheads are reconstructions based on remaining evidences of the originals. There were several later eighteenth, nineteenth and twentieth century porches.

The rear door of the original first building did not exist when the building was acquired, but the west jamb and a portion of the head existed, hidden behind modern weatherboards in the framing. The minder of the frame and the door now in place are reconstructions based on evidence found in the framing of the building. The door is a nine—panel door, and is hinged to fold back upon itself at the third—point. The reason for this will be explained in the interior notes. The west door, which opens into the western addition, is original, however, as is its frame and trim, with minor patching and repairs. At the time of restoration this door was found in a modern outbuilding and returned to its original location.

The two windows in the shed addition are entirely new, sized and located by indications in the framing. The window between the two doors is entirely new also. The two windows to the west of the west door retain their original sash and most of their frames and trim, patched and repaired. The west window, however, contains a new sash, and the bottom part of its frame and trim are new. The remainder of the frame and trim is original. Much original glass remains in the original sashes. All shutters and shutter hardware on this elevation are new.

The brick foundation wall under the shed addition is new, as noted under the east elevation. The brick wall under the rear porch is also new. The visible brick foundation wall of the western addition is mostly original, patched and repaired as necessary where a modern bulkhead had_been inserted. The grille under the middle window of the western addition is new, the original having been removed when a modern bulkhead was cut into the wall at this location.

WEST ELEVATION

When Henry Wetherburn built his first, symmetrical building there was, of course, a jerkin head at each end of the roof. When he added the western addition he simply continued the roof framing, enclosing the framing for the original western jerkin head, and at the new western end of the building repeated the feature. Thus he made the roof symmetrical, even though the dormers in it were not symmetrically arranged. The notes for the shingles, rake boards and weatherboards are the same as those for the east elevation. The south cornerboard is new, but the west face of the north cornerboard is original in place.

Page 6

The brick foundation wall is mostly original, patched and repaired as necessary. This wall was whitewashed and painted red in the nineteenth century, as were other parts of the foundation walls. Traces of this treatment are still visible.

FRAMING

The framing lumber in the building is almost entirely poplar. Since the building is unusually deep for a single span frame building (26'-0")the framing is arranged differently than it would be in a shallower building.

A large wood sill sits on top of the brick foundation walls around the building. Large girders running south—north are framed into this sill at intervals of around nine feet to frame the first floor. Running east—west between each of these there is a summer beam in the middle of the building except at the chimneys. Between the girders are typical floor joists. Almost all framing joints are mortice and tenon.

Framed into the sill are heavy vertical posts which support the second floor. There is a large post over each intersection of girder and sill, and between these are smaller typical studs except at the front door. There are also diagonal corner braces at the exterior corners. These posts and studs support a second floor structure which resembles the first floor framing except that the south—north girders in this floor are the bottom members of triangular wood trusses whose sloping top sides form the basic framing for the roof (see attached drawing). These trusses are located above the girders and posts below, and form a floor/roof structure of great strength which is capable of spanning the unusual depth of the building without undue sagging.

Between the heavy sloping roof truss members are light roof rafters which frame into horizontal members, called purlins (similar to summer beams), between the trusses. These purlins are hidden behind the plaster of the first building, but are visible in the western addition. The second floor ceiling framing consists of very light joists.

The framing of the western addition is an almost exact match to that of the original first building, and it may well be that the carpenter who built the first building also built the addition to it within a decade.

INTERIOR

The interior arrangement of rooms in Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern presents a logical plan of the first building, changed to some degree by the addition of a small rear wing and a large room added to the west. Both additions seem to have been built by Wetherburn, and therefore reflect the growing and changing needs of a well known and prosperous tavern.

When Wetherburn died in 1760, an inventory of his property was made which included his furnishings in the tavern. This inventory lists the. furnishings Page 7 room by room, and the rooms are named. This inventory has been related to the existing building, and room names have been assigned using it as a basis. The inventory, which is a part of the York County records, has been damaged to some degree, and some of the entries and room names are incomplete. See plans for room names.

BASEMENT

The entire basement of the restored building is given over to storage, mechanical and custodial spaces,'and is not to be viewed by visitors. The brick basement walls are largely original, and have been covered with simulated white wash. Much of the ceiling framing is also original, reinforced for stability and endurance. This framing is covered with new plaster The basement floor is new concrete except in the custodians rest rooms and lounge under the south portion of the Great Room, where the flooring is vinyl.

FIRST FLOOR

As noted above, the plan of the first portion of Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern is predictable from the exterior, and is in most ways typical of its period and local. A center passage containing the stairs runs from front to back through the building. On either side of this passage there is a large front room and a narrow rear room. The only unusual plan feature is the location of the fireplace and chimneys. The fireplaces occur at the inner corner of each of the first floor rooms, and face diagonally into the room. A more usual arrangement for this type of building would be for the fireplaces to be placed on the exterior end walls, and diagonally across the corners of the rooms. This sort of arrangement occurs in the Allen—Byrd House, the Archibald Blair House, and other examples in Williamsburg.

The pine trim of the first floor rooms as restored is very simple, and is basically the same in all the rooms. In all cases the baseboard is a simple board about 4" high with a ½" bead at the top, painted black. The chair board is a flat board of varying width with a ½" bead top and bottom. In the two front rooms and the Stair Passage of the first building there are peg strips fairly high on the wall. There are no cornices, and no panelling with the exception of the two panelled chimney breasts in the two front rooms of the first building.

Where new baseboard and chair board was needed it was copied from existing original examples in the building. Also, there is new framing material inserted in the floors, walls, etc. to reinforce the original framing.

The ceiling height throughout the first floor is approximately 10'-8".

The fireplaces throughout the building are plastered, as were the originals.

Page 8
BULLHEAD ROOM (16'-8" x 15'-10") North-East Room

The framing in the walls of the Bullhead Room, and most of the rooms in the building, is basically original.

The south door and trim are new, although the verticals of the frame are original. These iambs had been relocated in later eighteenth century alterations, but were found to have come from this location and were returned to it. The west door, frame and trim are new, framing indications only remaining to indicate its original location and size.

Only the frames and part of the trim of the two windows are original, the backbend and sash being new, copied from old examples within the building. All first floor windows had their lower sashes hung with sash cords and weights. The original sash cord, pieces of which were found, has been reproduced.

The baseboard in the room is new, copied from original material within the building. The chair board is basically original, patched as necessary. The peg strip is new, its original existence and location indicated by marks in the framing and original lath. Its design is copied from existing examples existing in other buildings in Williamsburg.

The fireplace and panelled chimney breast are new. The shape of the fireplace opening was determined by remaining original brickwork within the chimney. Evidence also existed that the fireplace had a marble surround, so a new one of proper design has been put in place. The panelling over the fireplace is designed to match a pattern of eighteenth century nail holes in the brickwork of the chimney. The cornice with the pulvinated (convex) frieze is new, adapted from an eighteenth century example. The small built—in cabinet to the right of the fireplace is partly original, although the door and frame are new.

The plaster in this room, and throughout the building with one exception on the second floor, is new. Its surface has been roughly worked in imitation of original plaster found in the building. What original plaster remained at the time of restoration was in such poor condition that it could not be saved, with the one exception already noted.

The flooring is largely original of random width heart yellow pine.

The paint color in this room, and all of the paint colors throughout the building, are copies of original colors found on original woodwork by paint investigation. The color is Blue—Grey #1255, and matches the first color applied. It is applied over a primer simulating the original Spanish Brown primer, this applies to all the trim colors throughout the building.

MR. PAGES ROOM (15'—8" x 18'—8") South—East Room

The unusual shape of this room evolved through the shed addition. The original rear room of the first building was wide and shallow, its rear wall Page 9 lining with the existing cased beam in the ceiling. When the shed addition was built this rear wall was ripped outs and its single window relocated in the east wall of the new shed. This alteration proved a trial to the structure of the building because, when the rear wall was removed the second floor (and hence the roof truss at that point) dropped noticeably at that pointy putting great strain on the structure. The framing condition has been corrected in the restorations although some sag still remains in the ceiling.

The small west door and its frame and trim are news the old location sizes etc. indicated by the original framing. The north door is new, as noted above, but the verticals of the frame are original.

All windows., frames and trim in the room are news the originals having been removed in the nineteenth century.

Much of the baseboard in the room is originate patched and pieced out as necessary. The same is true of the chair board.

The fireplace and surround are entirely news the shape of the fireplace obtained from original brickwork in the chimney. The marble surround is news of appropriate design.

The plaster in the room is new.

The pine flooring is largely original, pieced out and repaired as necessary.

The paint color is green #45, and matches the third eighteenth century color applied.

STAIR PASSAGE (9'-0" x 25'-0")

Sometime in the second quarter of the nineteenth century the interior arrangement of Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern was drastically altered. The original staird was completely removed as were the west wall of the stair passage and the large chimney behind it, and the eastwest wall between the Middle Room and the Chamber. Anew stair hall was created across the front of the houses partitions were rearranged to suit the new plans and much original work was discarded. This alteration was done to make the building more suited to residential use. Most of the elements of this alteration remained in place until the acquisition and restoration of the building by Colonial Williamsburg,, when they were removed and the original arrangement of partitions recreated.

The framing of the walls is largely original with the exception of the west wall where the framing and the brick chimneys whose back forms part of the walk are new.

Both the front and rear doors are news although the iambs of the front door and parts of those of the rear door are originals as explained in the notes on the north elevation. The rear (south) door is unusual in that it is a nine-panel doors three—panels wide and three high. The door is hinged back upon itself Page 10 at the third point, in order to clear the underside of the reconstructed stair landing. This is the only arrangement by which a door of the width indicated by the framing could open fully. The four doors into the four rooms off the Passage of the first building are entirely new, those in the west wall being located to reflect those in the east wall, where remaining framing indicated the location of the removed originals.

The baseboard, chair board and peg strips in this Passage are all new, located by indications in the framing and copied from existing examples.

The stair is a reconstruction. The size, location, slope, etc. of the stair were indicated by various marks in the floor, ceiling and walls. The details of the stair are copied and adapted from an existing original example of the same period in the Benjamin Walter House in Williamsburg. The stair is pine, with a natural finish poplar handrail.

The plaster in the stair passage is new.

The flooring near the front door is new to the building, the rest being original, somewhat patched and repaired.

The paint color is Dark Brown #168 and matches the second eighteenth century color applied.

MIDDLE ROOM (16'-8" x 15'-10" North Center Room

The framing of the north wall is largely original, but the framing of the other walls is almost entirely new, the original having been removed or relocated in the nineteenth century alterations.

All of the doors, their frames and the trim are new.

The west window frame on the north wall is original, but all sashes and trim we news copied from old examples within the building.

No original trim existed in this room, and consequently the baseboard, chair board and peg strips are news copied from existing old material in the buildings and matching that in the Bullhead room across. the hall.

The fireplace and panelled chimney breast are new, as is the chimney behind it. This chimney vas removed in the nineteenth century alterations, and the chimney now in place is a copy of the corresponding eighteenth century chimney across the passage. The details of the chimney and the panelling are adapted from the corresponding features of the other fireplace. The marble fireplace surround is adapted from fragments of an original example discovered in the archaeological excavations. The cornice with its pulvinated (convex) frieze over the chimney breast is a conjectural reconstruction copied from examples of the period. The small built—in cabinet to the left of the fireplace is copied from the partially original example across the Passage.

The plaster in the Middle Room is new.

Page 11

The flooring is about one—half original and one—half new.

The color is Blue—Grey #1255 and matches the first eighteenth century color applied.

THE CHAMBER (16'-8" x 8'-7") South Center Room

The framing of the south wall of the Chamber is largely original but like the Middle Room,to the north the framing of the remainder of the walls is mostly news the original framing having fallen victim to the nineteenth century alterations.

Both doors in the room are new, as are their frames and trim. Their locations correspond to the matching openings in the rooms across the Passage.

Both windows with their frames and trim are new. The south window corresponds to the one which was removed from the south wall of the small south room across the passage when the shed addition was built. The small window in the west wall matches that in the east wall of the small south room across the hall. When the western addition was built this window was left in place, and evidently functioned as a pass through from the bar in the western addition to the remaining eastern portion of the building.

No original trim remained at the time of the restoration and thus the baseboard and the chair board are news copied from old examples within the building.

The fireplace, surround, and wood mantel are news as is the chimney behind. Details are adapted from the fireplace in Mr. Pages Room across the Passage.

The plaster in the room is new.

The pine floor is largely new.

This room will be used as an office and lounge for the hostesses and will not be seen by the visitors. There is a small kitchen unit against the west wall and an electric panel on the south wall east of the window.

The paint color is light Ivory #1221, and matches the first eighteenth century color applied.

GENERAL

All of the rooms so far have been part of Wetherburn's first building and its small shed addition to the rear. At this pointy however we complete the first floor rooms in the first buildings and proceed to those in the western additions of the 1750's. These consist of a small entry a large public dining room and a small bar in the rear entry. The pine trim in these rooms matches that in the rooms in the first building.

Page 12
NORTH ENTRY (5'-2" x 8'-4" )

The framing of the north and west walls and the south wall (actually the north face of the large chimney) is original, but the east wall is new material, the original having fallen victim to the nineteenth century alterations.

The doors with their frames and trim are new, as is the transom over the north door.

The baseboard is new, copied from old examples in the building.

The plaster is new.

The flooring is mostly original.

The paint color is Dark Green #667, matching the second eighteenth century color applied.

THE GREAT ROOM (25'-8" —— East—West 25'-0" North—South) West Room

This large room comprises most of the first floor of the western addition and seems to have been the reason for it.

The framing of all the walls in the room is almost totally original. The framing of the ceiling is original, reinforced with steel necessitated by instability and a noticeable sag in the second floor.

Both doors in the east wall are new, as are the frames and trim.

All of the window sashes, their frames, and the trim are original, patched and repaired as necessary with the following exceptions: The west window on the south wall was made into a door in the nineteenth century. The sash now in place there, and the lower part of the frame and trim are new. There is much original glass in the original sashes. Also, the trim of the center window on the north wall is new.

The baseboard and the chair board are new, copied from remnants of the originals found in the building.

The upper portion of the marble surround of the fireplace is original to the room. The lower portions, however, are new. The originals were: removed long ago and fragments of them were found by archaeological investigations in the front and rear yards. These fragments provided information as to the molding profiles of these originals and were copied in the pieces now in place. The marble surround may have been intended to carry a narrow shelf, matching several others in Williamsburg, but there is evidence that such a shelf was ever installed. The brick hearth is new.

The plaster in the room is new.

Most of the flooring is original with the exception of the northwest Page 13 corner, which is largely refloored.

The color is Dark Green #667, matching the second eighteenth century color applied.

THE BAR (5'-2" x 8'-4")

The framing of the walls of this room,with the exception of the east wall, is largely original, somewhat patched and strengthened. The north wall is formed by the south side of the large chimney.

The door to the Great Room with its frame and trim is new, but the door to the rear porch is original, as is its frame and tram, patched and repaired as necessary. It is the only surviving exterior door,,and has been useful as a precedent for several reconstructed features in the building. The transom sash above the door is original.

The baseboard is new, copied from old examples in the building.

The bar consists of a broad shelf with a low panelled wall and door under it. The small space behind the bar holds a rack for barrels and the north wall has shelves and hooks for bottles, glasses, etc. A vertical sliding wood grill closes the bar when not in use. Marks were found in the flooring indicating the location of the bar. The other features were adapted from an English tavern print by Rolandson.

The east wall, which was the exterior wall of the first building, is sheathed with new flush beaded boards, those which were installed when the western addition. was built having disappeared long ago. The window in this wall is new, and the original was left in position when the addition was built, probably for use as a pass through.

The plaster is entirely new.

The pine flooring is mostly original, rather heavily worn by foot traffic to and from the Great Room, the bar, and the kitchen in the rear yard.

The paint color is Dark Green #667, matching the second eighteenth century color applied.

SECOND FLOOR

GENERAL

The pine trim in the second floor rooms of the first building matches that of the first floor rooms except that the chair board is not used. The baseboard is beaded as it is on the floor below. The trusses mentioned in the section of framing are visible in the sloping walls and are cased with flat boards having ½" beads at the corners. The dormers are typical and simple, and the only decoration being flat beaded trim around the sash, beaded corner Page 14 boards where the dormers intersect the sloping ceiling, and a wide window stool with a gedroon—profile edge. In the oldest portion of the building, the dormer sashes were not hung with sash cords and weights.

Where new trim was needed it was copied from existing original examples in the building.

The ceiling height throughout the second floor is approximately 7'-10".

As on the first floor the fireplaces are plastered, as were the originals.

THE ROOM OVER THE BULLHEAD (16'-8" x 21'-7") East Room

The framing in the walls and the sloping ceilings is almost entirely original, much reinforced with new material as it is throughout the second floor of the building.

The door to the Stair Passage is new, as its frame and trim, the size and location having been determined by indications in the original framing.

The dormer sash is all new, but the framing, window frames and parts of the trim of the north dormers are original as is the dormer framing. Only the framing of the south dormer is original, the remainder being new.

The baseboard is new, copied from old examples in place in the building.

The plastered fireplace and chimney is entirely modern, although the plan of the fireplace itself was evident from old brickwork remaining in the reworked chimney. The fireplace is a reconstruction of one which was installed in 1785 when Humphrey Harwood tore down the original chimney in this location (probably because of its poor condition) and rebuilt it. In the rebuilding he brought the flues for the first floor fireplaces up in such a way that a typical fireplaces flush or parallel to the wall., could not be built. Thus the unusual angled fireplace was constructed, the strange angles over the fireplace being the flue slanting back into line and the plaster reverse slope a method of supporting the chimney above.

The beams projecting from the sloping ceilings are the truss members referred to under "gaming", the casings for which are largely original.

The plaster in the room is new with the exception of the east wall which retains its eighteenth century plaster. When the first building was built there were two windows in this wall. Shortly after it was built, however, a small tenement or shop was built on the property immediately to the east. This building blocked the windows and they were removed at that time, thus the wall is covered with eighteenth century plaster of two dates that in the window locations being slightly later than. the rest of the wall. These windows have not been replaced, since the tenement next door may be reconstructed in the future.

Page 15

The flooring is mostly original.

The paint color is Buff #659, matching the second eighteenth century color applied.

STAIR PASSAGE (9'-2" x 16'-9")

Framing for partitions around the Passage are new with the exception of the east wall. The nineteenth century stair hall disrupted the original floors and walls in this area and almost all work in the area is new.

Both doors in the Passage are new, as are their frames and trim.

Only the framing, window frame and stool of the dormer window over the stair is original, the remainder being new. The truss casings are largely original.

The baseboard in the Passage is new. The ledge around two sides of the stair well is an unusual feature occasioned by the stair being narrower than the Passage in which it was built, and was probably used for access to the dormer window.

The stair, as noted in the first floor notes, is entirely new. The shape, size, slope, etc., being determined by marks and indications on the framing. The details of the stair are copied and adapted from an original example of the period in the Benjamin Waller House in Williamsburg. A pair of small batten doors at the landing provide access to a small storage closet over the rear portion of the first floor passage behind the stair.

The plaster in the Passage is new.

The floor is also new to the building, as much of this space was used as the well of the nineteenth century stair.

The paint color is Dark Brown #168, matching the second eighteenth century color applied.

THE PORCH CHAMBER (9'-0" x 4'-6") North of Stair Passage

With the exception of some of the framing of the sloping ceiling and part of the east wall, the framing in the walls of this root is new.

The door, its frame, and its trim are new.

The frame of the dormer window and part of its trim is original. The remainder, including the sash and stoop are new.

The baseboard is new copied from old examples in the building. The truss casing is original.

The plaster is new.

Page 16

The pine floor is new, as the nineteenth century stair well was cut into this area.

Passage (16'-8" x 8'-2")

The framing of the walls of the Passage is largely original only in the sloping ceiling of the north wall. The other walls are new, in a few cases refrained with old materials.

All three doors in the Passage, with their frames and trim, are new.

The framing and window frames of the dormer windows is original. With the exception of the head trim, the remainder of the east dormer is new. The west dormer, however, exhibits original sill and trim.

The baseboard is new. The truss casing is largely original.

The plaster is new.

The floor is almost entirely original.

The paint color is Dark Brown #168, matching the second eighteenth century color applied.

THE ROOM OVER MIDDLE ROOM (14'-3" x 13'-0") South Center Room in First Building

The framing of the walls in the room is basically original with the exception of the north end of the west wall, and the north wall which has been refrained with old material.

The closet door in the east wall and the hall door in the north wall are new, as are their frames and their trim.

The frame of the dormer window and its stool are original, the rest is new.

The baseboard is new, copied from old examples in the building. The truss casing is largely original. The fireplace is entirely news the original having been removed with its chimney in the nineteenth century alterations. The wood mantel and shelf is simple, adapted from local original examples.

The plaster is new.

The flooring in the south portion of the room is original, that in the north portion being new to the building.

The paint color is Red #759, matching the third eighteenth century color applied.

GENERAL

The rooms thus far on the second floor have been within the first Page 17 building built by Wetherburn. From this point on, however, the rooms form part of the western addition. Architectural investigations have shown that, as first built the second floor of the western addition comprised one large room, floored, trimmed and lathed but not plastered, and with the dormer sash and trim left unpainted. Sometime after the completion of the wing the second floor was partitioned into three rooms and a small Passage, and the rooms were plastered. The pine trim in the wing matches that in the first building. The only difference being that here the purlins (see the section on Framing) are exposed in front of the plaster; whereas, in the first building they were concealed behind it. Sash weights and cords were used on the second floor of the addition, as they were on the first floor.

THE SH... (16'-3" x 21'-7") South Center Room in Western Addition

The framing of the walls of this room is almost entirely original, with the exception of the north portion of the east wall.

The hall door in the east wall is entirely new but the door in the west wall is an old door found in the building. Its frame and trim are new.

The north dormer framing, window frame, stool and trim are original, the remainder being new. In the south dormer only the framing and the stool are original, all the rest being new.

The baseboard in the room is largely original, patched and repaired. The truss casings are also original.

The fireplace is original, as is a part of the arch over it. The simple wood mantel and shelf is new, adapted from local original examples.

The plaster is entirely new.

The floor is largely original with some patching near the two doors.

The paint color is Mustard #1408-W, matching the first eighteenth century color applied.

GENERAL

The small Passage and two rooms left in the second floor of the western addition will not be open to the visitor. They are intended for Hostess and mechanical uses, and therefore the finished floors, etc. are not necessarily restored to their original materials. The original flooring from these rooms was used for patching and replacement of worn or missing portions of the remaining flooring in the building.

SMALL PASSAGE (3'-2" x 10'-6")

This small Passage was originally constructed shortly after the wing was constructed, as noted above. It served to give a measure of privacy to the two end rooms.

With the exception of the east wall, all the framing of the Passage Page 18 walls is new.

The doors in the east and west walls are old, although the frames and trim are new. The door in the north wall is new. The door from the Passage into the Hostess rest room has been moved north from its original location so as to block the visitors view of the rest room.

With the exception of the framing, the dormer in the south wall is new.

The baseboard is new.

The plaster is new.

The flooring is new vinyl tile, and is a purely modern convenience in this non—public area.

The paint color is Mustard #1408-W, matching the first eighteenth century color applied.

THE ... EAT ROOM (11'-2" x 10'-5") South—West Room

The framing of the south and west walls is original, the framing of the north and east walls is new.

The east door is an old door, although the frame and trim are new. Its locations has been changed (see Small Passage). There were indications that there was another door in the norms wall opening into the End Room, but this door was not rebuilt in the reconstructed wall due to the prevent uses of the rooms.

In the dormer window in the south wall only the framing and the stool are original.

The baseboard is original on the south and west walls, new on the north and east walls.

The plaster is new.

The flooring is new vinyl tile, and is a purely modern convenience.

The paint color is Mustard #1408-W, matching the first eighteenth century color applied.

Note: This room is reworked to be a lavatory for the hostesses. The partitions around the toilet room, the closet, and the lavatory axe all new and not intended to reproduce eighteenth century arrangements.

THE END ROOM (14'-8"x10'-5") North—West Room

The framing in the west, north and east walls is original, that in the south being new.

Page 19

The door is new, as is its frame and trim. There may have been another door in the south wall (see The ... Eat Room).

The dormer windows retain their original framing as well as their original window frames, stools and trim.

The baseboard is original on the west and north walls, new on the south and east walls.

The plaster is new.

The flooring is new vinyl tile, and is a purely modern convenience.

The paint color is Mustard #145-W, matching the first eighteenth century color applied.

Note: This room is now used to house mechanical equipment.

OUTBUILDINGS

The yard behind Mr. Wetherburn's Tavern contained foundations of a typical complement of eighteenth century outbuildings. These had all disappeared above the ground, however, except for the framing of an original dairy, resided, re-roofed and relocated.

KITCHEN (Reconstructed)

EXTERIOR

Brick foundations were found for the large tavern kitchen. The building was approximately 40'-0" long and 16'-4" wide, built roughly parallel to the main tavern building.

The kitchen as reconstructed is in many ways a smaller model of the tavern building. Many of its details were copied or adapted from it, such as its jerkin—head roof shape and its round-butt cement asbestos shingles in imitation of wood. Its beaded weatherboards are adapted from those on the main building, as are the cornerboards. The double hung window sashes are adapted from original examples in the tavern building, as are the typical board and batten shutters and the simple batten doors, one into each room. The simple cornice is typical of service buildings, as are the narrow dormer windows. The detailing of the dormers echoes those on the tavern as does their hipped roofs. The large brick chimney is designed to hold the proper number and size of fireplace flues which would have been in use in the eighteenth century. The chimney cap profile is adapted from those on the tavern building.

The exterior of the tavern is painted with simulated whitewash over Spanish Brown primer.

Page 20
INTERIOR

The interior of the kitchen is divided into two rooms on the first floor. The division is accomplished by a massive brick chimney with large fireplaces opening into each room. The east room is 12'-6" x 15'-0", and the west room is 16'-0" x 15'-0". Both fireplaces are 8'-2" wide and 3'-2" deep. The arches over the fireplaces are 4'-3" high at the center. The first floor ceiling height is 7'-11".

The walls are of wood studs with brick nogging (infilling) between, all painted with simulated whitewash. The ceilings are plastered and also painted with simulated whitewash: All exposed framing is hand adzed.

The door and window trim is flat, beaded on the inside edge, and moulded with a small lambstongue on the outside. The partition between the rooms is a simple beaded board and batten wall with a batten door. The fireplace hearths are brick. The remainder of the floor is new pine, sawed and worked to match original examples.

The original building had no basement, but in order to house a modern heating plant for the tavern building the kitchen now has a basement. The basement is reached by a ladder in the floor of the closet at the west end of the west room under the stair. This closet and stair is hidden from view by a beaded board and batten wall. The stair is very steep, almost a ladder, with open wood breads and a simple beaded handrail.

The second floor of the kitchen is unfinished with only the insides of the dormers being plastered, since this surface is visible from the exterior. It is a low ceiling garret space, although amply lighted by dormer windows front and back, and by small square casement windows, one in each end wall.

DAIRY (Restored)

The dairy is the only outbuilding behind the tavern which retains arty original material. About twelve feet square, the frame of the building was found relocated in a group of modern outbuildings behind and west of the tavern. Its original foundation and use was determined by archaeological investigations. After its initial use as a dairy it was moved to the site of the reconstructed smokehouse and reworked in the late eighteenth century for use as a smokehouse. It was moved again in the early twentieth century. All visible materials on the exterior are new, adapted from local original examples. It is sheathed with whitewashed beaded random width flush boards. The door is a simple batten door with strap hinges. Around the north half of the building under the eaves is a wood grille to let air circulate through the interior.

The cornice has a wide overhang and consists of a simple crown mold and flat fascia. The roof is covered with round—butt wood shingles and capped with a wood finial copied from an original example which once capped the roof of a Providence Hall outbuilding.

Page 21

The plastered and whitewashed interior is divided into two spaces. The north portion with brick floor on grade, is a typical dairy interior. The south portion has a wood floor above grade and was probably used for cheese storage, etc. In the floor of the south room there is an opening through which a portion of the original brick foundation may be viewed.

SMOKEHOUSE (Reconstructed)

The smokehouse is entirely a reconstruction. Its original foundation walls were found and its use was. determined by archaeological investigation. It is about twelve feet square. The closely spaced studs in the wall (the close spacing intended to prevent pilfering) are covered on the exterior with whitewashed beaded weatherboards similar to those on the tavern. There is a typical simple batten door with strap hinges on the north elevat16n. The simple cornice consists of a crown mold and flat fascia. The roof is quite steep to facilitate the hanging of meats for smoking and is covered with round—butt wood shingles. There is an earth floor with a brick fire pit roughly in the center for a smoking fire. The roof is capped with a wood finial matching that on the Dairy and copied from the same source. The interior is whitewashed.

WELLHOUSE (Reconstructed)

The wellhouse is entirely a reconstruction ,painted with simulated whitewash,built over the remains (deep in the ground of an eighteenth century well. It is copied from an original example at Captain Orr's Dwelling. The wellhead is enclosed in a wood lattice and is roofed. The iron handle of the drum for raising the well bucket projects through the grille. The door in the wood grille, for access to the bucket, is a simple batten door. The well bucket and chain are exactly copied from originals which had dropped to the bottom of the well in the eighteenth century, and found there during the archaeological investigations.

PRIVIES (Reconstructed)

Archaeological investigations did not reveal the definite locations of arty eighteenth century privies, probably because the rear yard wash plowed and farmed in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The two reconstructions now in place are located logically and typically and are adapted from original local examples. They are covered with whitewashed beaded weatherboards., and roofed with round—butt wood shingles. The interiors are unfinished.

Page 22

LANDSCAPE

The Wetherburn's Tavern site has been developed to show the multifaceted activities in Mr. Wetherburn's day, with a more practical atmosphere of a working tavern prevailing, rather than a formal garden design. Archaeology revealed pavement patterns of brick, oyster shell marl, broken bottle bottoms and brickbats, immediately east of the main tavern building as well as between it and the kitchen. These materials have been used in the same areas, although somewhat adapted to meet present—day requirements of liability, maintenance and cleanliness.

To the rear of the kitchen and 6thar adjacent outbuildings is located a simple four—square kitchen garden, typical of the period, with flanking necessary houses in conventional locations. Small fruit trees and berries have been planted either side of the kitchen garden, and representative field crops occupy a plot adjacent to Botetourt Street. Mr. Wetherburn's estate listed an inventory of livestock, including six horses, four cons and seventeen sheep. The stable yard and paddock at the rear of the lot have been developed to reflect this activity, and future plans call for the present stable, reconstructed earlier as a four—car garage, to be fully completed and furnished as an exhibition stable.

Contents of the excavated Well C included fragments of many common fruits, vegetables and other plant materials, as follows: gourd seed 'and pits; squash seeds;plums, apricot and peach pits; pine needles; grapevine twigs; and branches from the Virginia piney red maple, mulberry, red oak, red cedar, black walnut, cottonwood and mountain laurel. Many bottles were found intact with cherry pits inside. Although evidence is not conclusive that any or all of these items were in fact growing on the sites many of these plant materials have been selected to be planted here at Wetherburn's, along with mares other authentic eighteenth century materials.

Records indicated that Wetherburn sold off the 40' x 56' corner portion of Lot 20 at the intersection of Duke of Gloucester and Botetourt Streets in 1759 to James Tarpley, merchant, from Yorktown, who had been operating in Williamsburg as early as 1752. He built a brick building prior to 1763. The present Tarpley stricture was reconstructed on old foundations in 1937. A fence has been erected to the rear of this store to reflect the eighteenth century ownership as defined above.